28 Mar 2008
My mom is from a big family. She has one older brother and four younger sisters. My aunts and uncle put together I have 6 cousins on my mother’s side. My dad has one older brother, one older sister and one younger sister. Again, 6 cousins from my father’s side. But there is a messy family politics(MUCH messier in my mother’ side than my father’s side) involved, in to which I choose not to dwell. Inspite of having shared the same womb, same blood, the extent to which the siblings would go to spite one another was something that scared (or should I say scarred) me for life. Through out school life, I missed having a sibling around. When you really want something, life has a way of giving it you. In my case, life gave me four( 3 + 1*) great friends. You know the coolest part? I could share good feelings, my sorrows, without having to share material things. Yippeee! Every thing has a silver lining folks, E.V.E.R.Y.T.H.I.N.G 🙂
Chula and Mieja 15 months apart and being the same sex, one doubt I had in my mind was – these girls are going to be competing for the same resources for the rest of their lives. That scared me. I do not want them to nurse grudges and let jealousy ruin their relationship.
One of my attempt to foster attachment is I try to make them communicate directly. For instance, if Mieja wants something, like a bottle opened, to be read a picture book, opening an umbrella and if I think Chula can handle it, I tell Mieja to ask her elder sister. Pretty soon, when Mieja can do more things, I plan to extend this role mutually (because I think 15 month old difference is too little to establish the older sibling – younger sibling hierarchy). So far Chula has obliged and is pleased as plum when she is being asked for help.
As a result of all this, I think Mieja thinks Chula is MUCH older than her. The other day Chula wanted me to read a book like her teacher (meaning, me sitting on a chair and read the book as if some one would read a book to a big group as opposed to our regular reading sessions in which both the children are piled up on my lap). Mieja walked in and tried to climb on my lap. I gently nudged her and pointed to the floor and asked her to sit on the floor, otherwise she will not be able to see the book. She immediately went and sat on Chula’s lap! Chula gladly indulged, ‘Oh baby. I can’t see. Here sit like this, now we both can see. Okay?’ That was totally cute 🙂
Another thing I have started doing, during bath time(which is common for the girls), I ask them each two questions. ‘What was that one good thing you did for your Chula/Mieja today?’, ‘What was that your Chula/Mieja did today, made you very happy?’
Chula invariably answers, ‘Amma, I scrub my sister’ or ‘I read a book for Mieja’ for the first question. For the second it is always, ‘Amma, Mieja came to my school to pick me up. I was so happy to see her.’
So far Mieja, being the Villupattu specialist she is, simply repeats the last word of her sister’s most recent statement. ‘I chub. I chub. Watuul.’, ‘Chula kool….’
Will they grow up to be good friends inspite of their differences? Only time can tell. Meanwhile, I am determined to do my best.
PS
*Boo, some how the ‘little sister’ image is plastered to my mind and hence I leave you out whenever I talk about friends. But you know what? Sisters can/must be friends. That’s what I expect from my girls. So from now on it is official, I have four great friends.
20 Responses for "Parent’s Role In Sibling Rivalry – I"
From what I see so far, there will always be differences, little jealousy and rivalry. But still I see the love, possessiveness and closeness between them growing everyday. The competition as to who wins more ‘wow’s , ‘good job’s’ , ‘hugs and kisses’ from the parents are still there, and I guess will always be there. They will just learn to handle it as they grow. Even as adults me and my sister compare about who gets more time with our parents etc, ofcourse we just joke about it now..but the comparison still comes up. It is not wrong to have differences even among friends….the more we deal with them makes our relationship grow stronger and makes it lasts longer. My two cents. 🙂
Hey UTBT
You wouldn’t know me I guess as I am not a mommy blogger. But I know Tharini and Kodi’s Mom through their blog that is.
Ok, now this request may sound weird but can you please mail me at the e-mail address provided. Trust me, I am not trying to sell anything and neither am I going to spam you or anything 🙂
thanks
sandeepa
Serious sibling rivalry is more common in siblings more than 2. So I don’t think you need to worry!!
One thing I can say from my own experience grwing up with sibblings – There will be phases when the sibblings won’t get along, especially at teen age, when they taste independence, have friends of their own, realise that their personalities don’t match. But, this period is very short. When out of it, the sibblings bond grows stronger than ever.
I think the way you are involving each others and having them communicate to each others directly is the key. When they are older and go into this phase of not-getting-along for whatever reasons, they will have the communication channel to talk it out and sort things out. I think this was completely missing in the previous generation.
But as you say, only time will tell. Until then we do what we think is best.
I think Parents play a vital role in sibling rivalry. The stuff they do matters a lot more than the stuff they dont. The comparisons, complimenting one kid, praising one kid in front of others, … these things matter a lot more than we would think and these are the stuff which makes or breaks a sibling relationship. This is such an interesting topic for me. Would love to hear more from you.
Sibling rivalry..ah, fun times.
Nothing like fighting like cats and dogs in childhood to strengthen the bond after growing up.
Ofcourse, too much fighting ain’t good either. But the usual quarrels are common, “my toy” ” my room” “my mom” “don’t wanna share”
As long as you make the older sibling love the younger, life won’t be cumbersome. Certain fights are going to happen. Specially when both are girls… ooo the times when they are ready to put on make up.. scary. But it can go the other way too. Both will gang up and try new stuff, …then you are gonna be in trouble because they will gang up on you and ‘borrow’ your products. Then again, I don’t know you yet..first time on this blog na…for all I know, the three of you may gang up and make poor ol dad lighten his wallet by buying lots of jewelry.
😛
anyway,
God that was cute…
I think I had such moments with my sis… though the main topic of discussion about my childhood with sis always ends up with her biting me in a restaurant:P
Man, gotta read more of your stuff… this is like having a great time and subconsciously getting experience in handling kids..
Far as i know, generalizing it now..they will be good now, with one or two fights maybe..teenage life can go either way…but after they finish with the teen..gotta believe it..they are gonna be inseparable.
Btw, since you don’t know me either..a small intro for now…will put a bigger one in my blog soon.. hershey Desai, I am a weirdly sane guy, unmarried so far, and leave long comments…. since its my first time here, I am leaving a short comment…
read the last 7 posts you have written, and loved em all..specially the one about the discussions.. funny!
catch you later… 65 more bloggers to go..really shouldn’t have made such a big list..this is time consuming…fun, but time consuming.
Yay a series after my heart. I have a couple of things to add in general about sibling rivalry..
1. It usually starts (and sometimes ends) when the younger one asserts his/her independence. This could be at age two or twenty. So while the older-younger roles work very well when they are kids, I think it’s much better for parents to facilitate siblings to accept each other as equals as they grow older. Because in some sense they are.
2. Sibling rivalry is usually initiated by the elder child. Because the younger one has never seen a parent’s undivided love. I think it’s important for parents to work with the elder child (not that the younger is exempt) early on. This should be easier because parents usually know their older child’s temperament very well.
3. As parents we need to NOT feel guilty about bringing a sibling home. I’ve read about those comparisons of a new baby to a new wife and they make me barf. It’s OK to keep that in mind when your child throws a tantrum so that you don’t overreact, but mostly it’s not a good thought to have. If we feel guilty of bringing a child home, then you don’t think the older one will pick on that and feed off it?
I personally would lean towards feeling that I am providing a privilege to my first born by bringing another baby home. A readymade playmate ! A confidant ! A person to plot with against the parents ! A family.
Oh yeah I bet you can tell that I’m the younger one here LOL 🙂
AND MOST IMPORTANT:
It depends on the children’s personalities more than it does on the spacing or gender. I think as parents we should focus on that more than worrying about the spacing issue. I know of people with 10 years gaps being closer than those with 15 month gaps.
Looking forward to Part II…
This was so insightful. And a great series to keep going. I picked up a couple of thoughts here that will help me to set the tone for the r’ship of my little ones. Thanks for that!
Poppins : Its obvious you have given a lot of thought to this. Loved reading your comment and the clear thoughts in it.
Looking forward to seeing more on this topic. I have one child and I have always wondered if he will miss out on siblings. I feel a lot o sibling rivalry stems not from age/gender but from the fact that one child needs more attention than the other. Perhaps the child has a wicked temper or is not doing well in school or whatever. To the other child, it seems unfair and perhaps in a way it is too. but what can the parents do? Would also love to hear your thoughts on being an only child.
Hi UTBT, delurking here. I’m a S/W Engineer interested in pursuing Child Development. I’m looking for a Masters program in Child Development. Wondering if you’re pursuing masters or taking classes in community college. If yes to the latter, will the credits from community college count towards masters prereqs? Would you be able to help me decide on the approach? Thanks in advance.
Hi Sandhya, welcome to my space. I am doing the courses in a community college. The advantages are the quarter system and lower fees. The disadvantages are, you do the same work as in any university, but you may end up not getting credits for your courses in an accredited university and you only get an Associate degree. Anyways, I am planning to set up a meeting with the college career counsellor. Will send you an email about what I uncover.
Dotmom, I always craved for an elder brother. It was not exactly boring at home. My mother’s younger sisters grew up in my house. But they were a good 12-15 years elder to me. I missed having some one close to my age to discuss stuff around the time I hit puberty. I was raised in a typical conservative South Indian family and went to all girls school and had severe restrictions to go out of the house and meet friends. My aunts were for all purposes from a previous generation and if I had talked about boy or other stuff, I would have raised eyebrows and there is only so much I can discuss with friends. So it was lonley. I strongly feel a child needs to have atleast one sibling. It is good company for the children and later after they grow up, the children provide a better support system for the parents. Two is better than one.
Thanks Tharini.
Poppins Mom, spoken like a perfect second born. In fact I expected this from you 🙂
Hershey, sure you are only 22? You have a valuable points, there will be fights and diferences, but there will also be bonding as long as the communication channels are open.
Boo, you are right. I always used to think how can two people be compared? People are appales and oranges, how can they be comapred. Especially I used to be compared to my book worm aunt (!!??). But in the past 22 months, I have, in my mind compared my children. Anways, thsi point abt cmapring gives me something to mucnh on, will write abt it in part II
DDMom, ‘there will be phases when they don’t get along’ – fodder for part II. Thanks for the input.
Yaadayaada, thanks.
San, I just need to be prepared for the disputes owing to the differences. Provided the foundation is strong, these disputes will matter to nothing. Such a valuable input. Thanks.
I am so earmarking your post for references later. Though my girls are further apart in age, I think I could use some of your tactics to create a better bond between them.
I think what YaadaYaada says is true – sibling rivalry is more pronounced in more than two siblings. I have seen it but I can’t say for sure because I never thought of it this way. In my opinion, parents/elders are responsible for creating a rivalry among siblings by comparing/ favoring or simply fanning the natural competitive urges in kids. It all seems so fun in the beginning but what they don’t stop to think about is the mess that will come out later when they grow up but harbor the same feelings. Looking forward to the next post in the series.
Hi Utbt – I agree with Boo. Parents role matters. Comparisons don’t help. At least negative comparisons – not just what he/she likes dislikes…
Also I think how parents treat their own siblings matters too..if the child sees the parent constantly cribbing about their own sibling – then the child learns to not love that aunt or uncle as much and I do think it also tells them that it is OK to be angry/bitter towards your own sibling…the reasons may very well be genuine – but at the least the child should be shielded from such conversations. Am not saying this in ref to you of course – I mean in genl – I have seen this happen…
Also – I come from a family of six and I am the youngest. The first five siblings were a pack – I was born seven years later – so the minimum diff is 7 years between me and the sister above me. But I can relate very well to the oldest sibling just as well…it is just a different kind of relationship…I do very much wish my siblings were closer to me in age – but most times I am just grateful I have loving siblings. We all have our share of differences of opinion, esp when it comes to politics, religion etc…and we also have quarrels every now and then because one sibling gets upset that I did not visit her/him long enough etc…but there is that underlying feeling that we are all sure of – when it really matters we will be there for each other…and that comes from how my dad and mom treated their own siblings…esp my dad – he would have given his life for his older brother…
hi utbt, my first comment on your site! I agree with boo. I think it all depends a lot on what your parents said or did. It also works as a disadvantage if there are social and financial differences amongst siblings. Also I typically have seen this to be greater with siblings of the same sex.
One of the biggest positives of having siblings is that of a common language binding them- certain intra-family terms, jokes, abbreviations etc. that only they will know, particularly when they gang up against their parents. Whether they are particularly close as adults or not, the comfort level of being with a person with whom each has spent their earliest years and have their earliest memories of- that is a great bond indeed. But it is often marred by perceived or actual injustices on the part of the parents. A tricky path to tread….
I like the thought you are putting into it- it sounds very positive and effective.
Hey UTBT, thanks a ton! I didn’t expect you to reply 😉
Sandhya – you are welcome.
Dipali, you hit the spot. Thats just exactly what I longed for when I was in school – that common language thingy. As I have mentioned it several times in the blog, did experience it in college with my friends. We all still giggle away to glory talking about how it was in college, which the husbands think is absolutely absurd.
Pinochy, welcom. You have a valid point about the financial differences.
Noon, it was so nice to read about your loving family.
Cee kay, you are book marking this series. So are Boo and Tharini. So does all this mean that I have to put real thought in to the next post on this series? The focus lights are on, I am sweating, I can feel the pressure 🙂
Oh yeah! We are w.a.t.c.h.i.n.g. you sista!
Actually, just last night (or was it this morning?) I was thinking of implementing some of your ideas on my daughters. The older one is fine – loves the little one dearly, shares her things with her and all that. It is the younger one I am worried about (maybe unnecessarily so – it is too early to tell). I want her to love her elder sister back with the same intensity. I know I can’t force it, but I want to nudge it in the right direction if I can.
always great to read your posts!
Choxbox, you must share with us how you were set limits with your siblings and how it helped you manage you own children’s squabbles. Being the only child, I sometimes think that my children are the only ones fighting and get disillusioned 🙂
Leave a reply