8 Apr 2008
Chula: Amma, I want to be a princess.
(Meaning, she wants to wear her silk skirt – pattu pavadai)
Chula, looks at me wearing a yellow saree and exclaims, ‘Wow amma. You are a yellow princess.’
Chula: Amma, I am a princess.
Chula commenting about something: Amma, this is so beautiful, just like a princess.
At school, Chula’s friend’s mom says ‘hi’ to Chula. Chula shyly moves away, she wants nothing to do with this lady, she is hiding behind me with her face stuck to my back. But the minute the lady remarks, ‘Wow, look at you. You are all dressed up, just like a princess’, she immediately gravitates to the lady, sits on her lap and starts a conversation. The transformation was so abrupt that it made my jaw drop in shock.
Even little Mieja uses the P-word frequently. “I want pisses”. (Pisses = Princess)
All this is troubles me. In the past, I have ignored it, I have acknowledged it, I have denied it. I have no problem with princesses/princes/fantasy play/fairly tales. I believe that the purpose of fairy tales is to provide children with emotional sustenance. The original stories have messages about valor, values and highlight the qualities that bring an individual close to greatness. What I don’t like is today’s trend of throwing the original message in to dumps and focusing only on the external appearance. Most young girls are strongly attracted to qualities like fair, pure, serene. So today’s princesses commercial market projects ONLY beauty.
I know that hate is a strong word, but I have no qualms using it in this context. I hate the way the princess image is plastered in to these little minds. I hate the way so much unspoken message is given through these blond hair and blue eyed princess. I strongly hate the pathetic attempts at cultural sensitivity by introducing Jasmine, Pocahontas and Mulan. They are as inappropriate and out of context as the tan skinned, saree-wearing Barbies that are marketed in India. Have any one read the capsule version of Snow White/Beauty And The Beast/Cinderella? In order to present the story in a jiffy, most of the essential symbolism is trimmed down and the end product is five pages of absolute injustice to children’s literature, which sabotages the minds of young girls in to thinking that they ‘need’ prince charming to save them.
Some one needs to tell these kids that appearance does not make a princess, but it is the great human qualities and inner beauty counts. How about telling these kids about Joan of Arc or the Jhansi Rani Lakshmi Bai?
So in the past I have ignored the P-word. I have also denied it. But now, I am slowly learning to accept it. The reason is, the more I resist it, the more enticing it is going to sound to Chula and Mieja. We have princess stuff in moderation at home. (Okay, okay, we have one princess lunch bag and one Snow White storybook. Well, something is better than nothing.) Whenever they want to play with the lunch bag or the story read to them, I oblige. But the Snow White story I read to them is MY version. Where Snow White’s ‘happy go lucky/making the best out of the situation she is in’ attitude is highlighted. And Chula strongly believes that ‘the prince’ who saves Snow White is her father. (‘Amma, appa is taking good care of Snow White’. Yay! Sexist message is taken care of.)
Any ways, when ever I hear the P-word in association with external appearance, I keep reiterating that princess-ness (my audacity for coining new words is purely derived from my inability to pick the right word from the million words that already exist in English language) does not come from the clothes, that she is a princess all the time, because she is loving, lovable and intelligent. And that’s what makes a princess.
Edited to add: United they stand, Divided they fall. Thanks Balaji making me put my finger on something that I have started doing subconsciously. I break the princesses by names. It is Cinderella, Snow White..( and others…Dang, I first need a princess101 ). It gives the ‘Princesses’ certain human-ness. The generality just gives them more mystery and unapproachability. Reference by name gives the message that they are human beings, fantasy but still human.
13 Responses for "The Magical World Of Princesses"
Blame it on Disney! It was actually considered a marketing masterstroke for Disney when they grouped and marketed all their heroines under 1 tag ‘Princess’. Thats what helped them beat Barbie. Kavya is princess-obsessed too from her pillow to her lunch box to her Halloween costumes. But looking at the glass as half-full, I’d be happier if she has Princess as her role-model and looks for Prince Charming rather than have Barbie as her role-model and look for a surfer dude named Ken 🙂
LOL Balaji, choosing between the devil and the deep sea? I did have the above mentioned corp in my mind, but didn’t want to name any names 🙂
Thanks for bringing up the labeling the all princess under one tag, which brings to my mind another point. How I forgot to mention in the post, I wonder! I will add this point as an edit to the post.
Balaji beat me to it! I am thinking of passing on the Barbie Ashu got as a present from a friend to Chula (Its still hidden in our car trunk!) since you are so accepting and all!! 😉
Princesses are so much more tolerable than Barbie. Ashu still does nt know the P word, she uses Doll instead looking at some Princess Dolls she has got. But of course, school next year will make her all older and wiser while graying my hair!! But then, all I ever wanted was a Barbie when I was 10 years old. I ll get back to you in a couple of years on this topic, ok?
Ah, I remember the good old days when I longed for a Barbie. I think I was 13 at that time 🙂
You are planning on passing the barbie to Chula??? Why what did I ever do to you? I demand that rethink.
hi, you are five years old and impressionable.
Joan of Arc.. Cinderella.. Joan of Arc.. Cinderella… death.. kiss from prince..death.. kiss from prince.. lets see…
oh please.. I am not a five year old girl but would venture a guess that the odds are stacked against Joan of Arc..
🙂
LOL at Sundars comment. You are a pro at this, are nt ya Sundar? 😉
Sundar, obviously you have been through this 🙂
You have raised a valid point, but the reply to that is a separate post, which I will do by the end of the week.
Very interesting post. I think acceptance is a sound step forward. And I think you’re doing a great job giving them the complete version of the story. I love to note the way you analyse things and internalise them and come up with a way to deal with that.
There was a article in the ‘San Jose Mercury News’ a few weeks back on the commercialization of the ‘Princess’ concept. I believe it had statistics showing how Disney was revived. Let me see if I can find the link.
Thanks C, do pass on the link if you find it.
Tharini, I analyze and at times over analyze 🙂
My three year old is totally obsessed with Cinderella, but that had started even before she saw her on Disney. I used to tell her the Cinderella story as I knew and she used to have fun running around and losing one slipper(a simple bata one) and all. Then we bought the Disney Cinderella and we are still debating whether it was a good move. Since then she always wants to wear a long skirt that she can pick up and run, she wants a glass slipper(at least one that has a nice heel) that can easily come off so she can continue running and losing the slipper. Although she has read all other stories we have not got any CDs for her yet. But girls will be girls I suppose, my husband did try to get her interested in Jungle book and Tarzan, but she is just not interested in those. I hope they outgrow this phase. Meanwhile here’s an article that also talks of the same thing.
http://parenting.kaboose.com/behavior/emotional-social-development/the-princess-debate.html
V, thanks for the link. Sorry for taking a long time to get back.
The link was so timely, as the book I am reading for the past three weeks is ‘Uses of Enchantment’ by Bruno Bettelheim !
May be this is a sign that I HAVE to get started on a post that I have in my mind – my opinion of fairy tales.
[…] back to the conversation we were having, UTBT’s post on princess flashed and I thought I had something to say. You know, this blog addiction does […]
Leave a reply